How to Bypass Throttle Position Sensor: A Guide to Overcoming Restrictions

In today’s fast-paced world, where speed and performance are highly valued, finding ways to bypass restrictions and push the limits has become a necessity for many enthusiasts. One important component that can pose challenges in this endeavor is the Throttle Position Sensor (TPS), which is responsible for relaying vital information to the engine control module. While the TPS is designed to ensure optimal performance and safety, some individuals may feel the need to disable or circumvent it for various reasons. This article serves as a comprehensive guide, offering insights and techniques on how to bypass the throttle position sensor and overcome the limitations that may hinder your quest for enhanced power and efficiency.

Before delving into the specifics of bypassing the throttle position sensor, it is crucial to understand its role in the overall functioning of a vehicle. The TPS is a sensor that measures the position of the throttle valve and communicates this information to the engine control unit (ECU). The ECU then adjusts the fuel injection and ignition timing accordingly, ensuring the engine operates at its optimum level. This process not only guarantees fuel efficiency but also enhances overall performance and prevents potential damage to the engine. However, there are instances where individuals may desire to override or bypass the TPS for a range of reasons, such as modifications to the engine or a desire for increased control over the vehicle’s power output. This guide aims to provide valuable insights and techniques on how to bypass the throttle position sensor effectively, while also highlighting the importance of being mindful of potential consequences and legal implications.

Table of Contents

Understanding the Throttle Position Sensor (TPS)

A. Explanation of how the TPS works

The throttle position sensor (TPS) is a crucial component of the engine control system in a vehicle. It is responsible for monitoring the position of the throttle plate and providing feedback to the engine control unit (ECU). The TPS works on a simple principle: as the driver presses on the accelerator pedal, the throttle plate opens, allowing more air into the engine. The TPS then detects the angle of the throttle plate and sends this information to the ECU, which uses it to determine the appropriate amount of fuel to inject and the ignition timing.

The TPS consists of a sensor and a potentiometer. The sensor is usually a contactless type, such as a Hall-effect sensor, which measures the position of the throttle plate. The potentiometer provides voltage signals to the ECU based on the throttle plate position. These voltage signals are used by the ECU to calculate the throttle opening angle.

B. Importance of the TPS in regulating engine performance

The TPS plays a vital role in regulating engine performance by ensuring the right fuel-air mixture and ignition timing. By accurately measuring the throttle position, the TPS helps the ECU make precise adjustments to the engine’s fuel delivery and ignition timing. This translates into optimal engine performance, fuel efficiency, and emissions control.

The TPS also enables the ECU to adjust the engine’s response to driver input. For example, when the driver suddenly depresses the accelerator pedal for quick acceleration, the TPS sends a rapid increase in voltage signals to the ECU, signaling the need for more fuel and an advanced ignition timing. This allows the engine to deliver the desired power promptly.

Overall, the TPS is a critical component for maintaining proper engine operation and performance. It ensures the engine responds accurately to the driver’s commands while also meeting emission standards.

In the next section, we will explore the reasons why someone might want to bypass the throttle position sensor and the potential benefits and drawbacks associated with bypassing it.

IReasons to Bypass the Throttle Position Sensor

A. Overview of common situations that may require TPS bypass

The throttle position sensor (TPS) is an integral part of a vehicle’s engine management system, responsible for communicating the position of the throttle plate to the engine control unit (ECU). While the TPS plays a crucial role in regulating engine performance, there are certain situations where bypassing it may be necessary.

One common reason to bypass the TPS is when it becomes faulty or malfunctions. A faulty TPS can lead to issues such as poor acceleration, irregular idling, or even engine stalling. In such cases, bypassing the TPS can serve as a temporary solution to restore engine performance until a proper replacement can be installed.

Another situation that may require TPS bypass is when performance modifications are made to the vehicle. Upgrading the engine, installing a turbocharger, or adding high-performance parts may alter the throttle response and make the stock TPS settings inadequate. Bypassing the TPS allows for manual adjustment of throttle position, enabling optimal engine performance in modified setups.

Furthermore, TPS bypass can be beneficial in off-road scenarios where restrictions imposed by the TPS can hamper performance. Off-road vehicles often require a wider throttle range or more aggressive engine response than what the stock TPS allows. Bypassing the TPS in these cases grants greater control over the throttle, enhancing off-road capabilities and maneuverability.

B. Benefits and potential drawbacks of bypassing the TPS

Bypassing the TPS can offer several benefits, depending on the specific situation. One advantage is the ability to fine-tune the throttle response according to individual preferences or performance requirements. This can result in improved acceleration, smoother power delivery, and enhanced overall driving experience.

Additionally, bypassing the TPS can offer a cost-effective solution compared to replacing a faulty sensor. It allows for more immediate remediation of performance issues, saving time and money while troubleshooting the root cause of the TPS malfunction.

However, it is important to note that bypassing the TPS may also have potential drawbacks. One major concern is that overriding the TPS can lead to increased fuel consumption and reduced fuel efficiency, especially if the TPS is bypassed without proper adjustments or calibration. Care must be taken to ensure that the modified throttle position aligns with the engine’s fuel mapping for optimal efficiency.

Another potential drawback is the risk of compromising vehicle safety. The TPS acts as a safety measure, preventing excessive throttle opening during abnormal conditions or malfunctions. Bypassing the TPS removes this safeguard and requires extra caution and responsibility while operating the vehicle.

Ultimately, the decision to bypass the TPS should be made based on careful consideration of the specific circumstances, potential benefits, and drawbacks. It is recommended to consult with automotive experts or professionals who can provide appropriate guidance and assistance in bypassing the TPS effectively and safely.

RecommendedPrecautions and Safety Considerations

A. Importance of proper knowledge and experience before attempting a bypass

Bypassing the throttle position sensor (TPS) can be a complex process and should only be attempted by individuals with proper knowledge and experience in automotive mechanics. It is crucial to have a clear understanding of the TPS and its function before proceeding with any bypass method. Lack of knowledge can result in damage to the vehicle or even personal injury.

Before attempting a TPS bypass, it is advisable to research and gain a thorough understanding of the specific make and model of your vehicle. Familiarize yourself with the engine system, wiring connections, and any specific instructions provided by the manufacturer.

B. Ensuring safety measures are in place to prevent potential harm or damage

Safety should always be a priority when working with any automotive system. Here are some important safety considerations to keep in mind when bypassing the throttle position sensor:

1. Disconnect the battery: Before starting any work on the TPS or its associated components, it is crucial to disconnect the vehicle’s battery. This will help prevent accidental electrical shock and reduce the risk of damaging any electronic components.

2. Use proper tools and equipment: Make sure you have the necessary tools and equipment to safely perform the bypass. This may include socket wrenches, screwdrivers, multimeter, wire connectors, and protective gear such as gloves and safety glasses.

3. Follow manufacturer guidelines: Always refer to the manufacturer’s instructions or service manual when working on your vehicle. Each vehicle may have specific safety precautions and guidelines that need to be followed.

4. Double-check connections and wiring: Before reconnecting the battery or starting the engine, it is essential to double-check all the connections and wiring modifications made during the bypass process. Incorrect connections can lead to engine malfunctions or other issues.

5. Test in a controlled environment: When attempting a TPS bypass for the first time, it is recommended to test the modifications in a controlled environment. This can be done in a garage or workshop, where you can monitor the engine’s performance and address any issues that may arise.

By following these precautions and safety considerations, you can minimize the risk of potential harm or damage while bypassing the throttle position sensor. It is crucial to prioritize safety and take the necessary steps to protect both yourself and your vehicle during the bypass process.

Method 1: Adjusting TPS Settings

Step-by-step instructions for adjusting TPS settings within manufacturer limits

In this section, we will explore the first method to bypass the throttle position sensor (TPS) by adjusting its settings within the manufacturer limits. This method can help improve engine performance without completely bypassing the TPS.

1. Gather the necessary tools: Before starting, ensure you have the required tools, including a screwdriver, multimeter, and a set of jumper wires.

2. Locate the TPS: The TPS is usually located on the throttle body and may have three wires connected to it. Refer to your vehicle’s service manual for more specific instructions.

3. Disconnect the TPS: Carefully disconnect the electrical connector from the TPS. Use caution to avoid damaging any wires or connectors.

4. Measure the voltage: Set your multimeter to the voltage setting and connect the positive lead to the TPS signal wire. Connect the negative lead to a ground point on the vehicle.

5. Adjust the TPS: With the multimeter connected, slowly adjust the TPS to change the voltage reading. Refer to your vehicle’s service manual for the proper voltage range. Stay within the manufacturer limits to ensure optimal performance and avoid any potential damage.

6. Test engine performance: After adjusting the TPS, reconnect the electrical connector and start the engine. Take note of any changes in engine performance, such as improved throttle response or smoother acceleration.

7. Fine-tune if necessary: If you are not satisfied with the initial adjustment, repeat steps 4-6 to make further adjustments. Be cautious not to exceed the manufacturer limits.

Explanation of potential improvements to engine performance with adjusted settings

By adjusting the TPS settings within the manufacturer limits, you can potentially improve engine performance in several ways.

1. Enhanced throttle response: Fine-tuning the TPS settings can result in improved throttle response, enabling the engine to respond more quickly to driver input.

2. Smoother acceleration: Adjusting the TPS can help eliminate any hesitation or jerking during acceleration, providing a smoother driving experience.

3. Optimal fuel efficiency: By ensuring the TPS is properly calibrated, you can achieve better fuel efficiency as the engine operates at its optimal performance.

4. Better idle stability: Correct TPS settings contribute to stable idle speed, reducing the risk of stalling or rough idling.

5. Reduced emissions: When the TPS is adjusted correctly, the engine can operate more efficiently, leading to reduced emissions.

It is important to note that adjusting the TPS settings should be done within the manufacturer limits to prevent any potential damage to the engine. If you are unsure about this process, it is recommended to seek professional assistance to ensure proper adjustment and avoid any negative consequences.

Method 2: Installing a TPS Bypass Module

A. Introduction to TPS bypass modules and their functionality

In some cases, adjusting the throttle position sensor (TPS) settings may not be sufficient to bypass the restrictions imposed by the TPS. This is where installing a TPS bypass module can come into play.

A TPS bypass module is a device that intercepts the signals between the TPS and the engine control unit (ECU), allowing you to bypass the TPS and directly control the engine’s performance. It essentially tricks the ECU into thinking that the throttle is in a different position than what the TPS is actually signaling. This can provide more control over the engine’s performance and potentially overcome any limitations imposed by the TPS.

B. Step-by-step instructions for installing a bypass module

Installing a TPS bypass module requires some technical knowledge and experience with automotive wiring. Here are step-by-step instructions to guide you through the installation process:

1. Begin by disconnecting the vehicle’s battery to ensure safety during the installation process.

2. Locate the TPS and carefully disconnect its wiring harness. Take note of the wire colors and their corresponding positions.

3. Connect the TPS bypass module to the TPS wiring harness. Ensure that the module’s connections correspond correctly to the TPS wires.

4. Connect the TPS bypass module to the ECU wiring harness. Again, make sure the connections are accurate and secure.

5. Double-check all connections to ensure they are properly secured and insulated.

6. Reconnect the vehicle’s battery.

7. Start the engine and test the bypass module. Observe any changes in the engine’s performance.

Note: It is important to keep in mind that the specific installation process may vary depending on the make and model of your vehicle, as well as the type of TPS bypass module you are using. Therefore, it is always recommended to refer to the manufacturer’s instructions and guidelines for your specific bypass module.

Installing a TPS bypass module can provide an effective solution for overcoming throttle position sensor restrictions. However, it is essential to exercise caution and follow all safety protocols during the installation process to avoid potential damage to the vehicle or harm to yourself.

Remember, bypassing the TPS may have implications on the legal and ethical aspects, as discussed in Section Always ensure that you comply with local laws and regulations when modifying your vehicle’s systems.

Method 3: Modifying Wiring Connections

Introduction to Modifying Wiring Connections

In some cases, modifying the throttle position sensor (TPS) wiring connections can be an effective method to bypass the restrictions imposed by the TPS. This method involves making alterations to the wiring in order to manipulate the signal sent to the engine control unit (ECU). It is important to note that modifying wiring connections should only be attempted by individuals with advanced knowledge and experience in automotive electronics.

Detailed Instructions for Wire Modification Technique

Before proceeding with this method, it is essential to disconnect the vehicle’s battery to avoid any potential electrical hazards. Follow these step-by-step instructions to modify the wiring connections:

1. Identify the TPS wiring harness: Locate the TPS and carefully identify the wiring harness that connects it to the ECU. This harness usually consists of three or four wires, including a reference voltage wire, a ground wire, and one or two signal wires.

2. Determine the signal wire: Use a multimeter set to measure voltage to identify the wire that carries the TPS signal. This wire will display varying voltage values as the throttle position changes.

3. Cut the signal wire: Once the signal wire has been identified, carefully cut it, ensuring that the cut is clean and precise. It is essential to leave enough length on both ends to allow for future reconnections, if necessary.

4. Install a variable resistor: Connect a variable resistor between the two cut ends of the signal wire. The resistance should be adjustable to mimic different throttle positions. This variable resistor will manipulate the signal sent to the ECU and bypass the TPS restrictions.

5. Secure the connections: Use electrical connectors or soldering to secure the connections between the cut ends of the signal wire and the variable resistor. Ensure that the connections are well-insulated to prevent short circuits or loose connections.

6. Reconnect the battery: Once the modifications have been made, reconnect the vehicle’s battery and start the engine to test the results. The engine performance should reflect the adjusted throttle position signal.

Considerations and Potential Drawbacks

It is crucial to understand that modifying the TPS wiring connections is an intricate process that carries potential risks. Improper modifications or incorrect readings from the variable resistor can lead to engine malfunctions or damage. Additionally, this method may not be suitable for all vehicles, as TPS wiring configurations may vary between models.

It is highly recommended to consult a professional or seek guidance from experienced individuals before attempting to modify the TPS wiring connections. Safety precautions, such as wearing protective gloves and eyewear, should also be followed to minimize the risk of electrical accidents.

Overall, while modifying wiring connections can be a viable method to bypass the TPS, it should be approached with caution and proper expertise.

Method 4: Reprogramming the Engine Control Unit (ECU)

A. Overview of reprogramming process and its benefits

Reprogramming the Engine Control Unit (ECU) is another method to bypass the throttle position sensor (TPS) and overcome the restrictions imposed by it. The ECU is responsible for controlling various aspects of the engine’s performance, including fuel injection, ignition timing, and throttle response. By reprogramming the ECU, you can alter the way it interprets and responds to the TPS signal, effectively bypassing its limitations.

Reprogramming the ECU offers several benefits. Firstly, it provides a more precise control over the engine’s performance, allowing you to customize it according to your preferences. This can result in improved throttle response, increased power, and enhanced fuel efficiency. Additionally, reprogramming the ECU can eliminate any artificial limitations imposed by the TPS, enabling the engine to reach its full potential.

B. Proper tools and equipment needed for ECU reprogramming

Reprogramming the ECU requires specific tools and equipment to ensure a successful bypass. Firstly, you will need an OBD-II (On-Board Diagnostics) scanner or a diagnostic tool that is compatible with your vehicle’s make and model. This tool will allow you to connect to the ECU and access its programming.

Once you have the necessary diagnostic tool, you will also need a laptop or computer with software that is capable of communicating with the ECU. This software will enable you to read the existing ECU programming and make the necessary modifications.

It is crucial to note that ECU reprogramming should only be attempted by individuals with proper knowledge and experience. Modifying the ECU programming without understanding its intricacies can lead to irreversible damage to the engine or other components.

Additionally, it is vital to ensure that any modifications made to the ECU programming comply with local laws and regulations. Some regions have strict emissions standards, and altering the ECU programming to bypass the TPS may not be permissible.

In conclusion, reprogramming the ECU is an advanced method to bypass the throttle position sensor and overcome its restrictions. It offers the benefits of improved engine performance and customization. However, it should only be undertaken by experienced individuals who have a thorough understanding of the ECU programming process. Adhering to local laws and regulations is also essential to avoid any legal implications.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

Explanation of potential legal implications and repercussions of TPS bypass

Bypassing the throttle position sensor (TPS) may be tempting for those seeking enhanced engine performance, but it is essential to consider the legal and ethical implications of such actions. While the process itself may not be expressly illegal, it can lead to legal consequences depending on the jurisdiction and circumstances.

One of the primary legal concerns associated with TPS bypass is the violation of emissions regulations. Most countries have strict laws regarding vehicle emissions, and modifications that disrupt the TPS can potentially result in increased emission levels. This can subject the vehicle owner to fines and penalties if caught during an emissions inspection.

Additionally, tampering with the TPS can also void the warranty of the vehicle. Manufacturers often void warranties if they detect modifications that compromise the original design and specifications of the vehicle. This can leave the vehicle owner responsible for any repairs or damages that would have otherwise been covered under warranty.

Encouragement to always adhere to local laws and regulations

To ensure compliance with local laws and regulations, it is strongly recommended to consult and adhere to the guidelines set by automotive regulatory authorities and governing bodies in your region. These organizations often provide clear guidelines on vehicle modifications, emissions standards, and legality.

It is important to note that some jurisdictions may allow certain modifications to the TPS within specific limits. Before attempting any modifications, it is crucial to research and understand the local regulations that govern vehicle modifications. In some cases, seeking professional advice from mechanics or experts in automotive modification can provide valuable insights into the legality of TPS bypasses.

Ethically, it is essential to consider the impact TPS bypasses can have on the environment. Increased emissions resulting from modifications can contribute to air pollution, impacting both human health and the environment. Being responsible stewards of the environment means balancing our desire for enhanced performance with the responsibility to minimize our ecological footprint.

In conclusion, while bypassing the TPS may offer potential benefits, it is vital to consider the legal and ethical implications. It is recommended to thoroughly research the local laws and regulations, consult with experts, and make informed decisions that align with legal and ethical standards. Adhering to these considerations will ensure a responsible approach to modifying your vehicle’s TPS.

Troubleshooting Common Issues

Identification of potential problems that may arise during TPS bypass

When bypassing the throttle position sensor (TPS), there are a few common issues that may arise. It is important to be aware of these potential problems in order to troubleshoot and address them effectively.

One possible issue is an inaccurate reading from the TPS. This can occur if the TPS is not properly calibrated or if there is a malfunction with the sensor itself. Inaccurate readings can lead to improper fuel delivery and engine performance issues. To address this problem, double-check the TPS settings or consider recalibrating it according to the manufacturer’s instructions. If the TPS is faulty, it may need to be replaced.

Another common issue is poor throttle response or hesitation. This can happen when the TPS bypass is not properly implemented or when the TPS settings are not adjusted correctly. To troubleshoot this issue, double-check the bypass method used and ensure that all connections are secure and properly installed. If the TPS settings have been adjusted, make sure they are within the manufacturer’s recommended limits. If the problem persists, it may be necessary to consult a professional mechanic or technician for further assistance.

Suggested solutions for technical difficulties

If you encounter technical difficulties during the TPS bypass process, there are a few suggested solutions that can help troubleshoot and resolve these issues.

First, it is important to double-check all the connections and wiring involved in the TPS bypass. Ensure that all connections are secure and that there are no loose wires or damaged components. If any issues are identified, repair or replace the affected parts as necessary.

If you are experiencing poor performance or other engine issues after the TPS bypass, it may be helpful to revert back to the original TPS settings or bypass method. This can help determine if the bypass is the source of the problem. Monitor the engine performance after reverting to the original settings to see if the issues are resolved. If they persist, it may be necessary to consult a professional for further diagnosis and repair.

In some cases, technical difficulties during the TPS bypass process may require the assistance of a professional mechanic or technician. If you are unsure or uncomfortable with troubleshooting or making modifications to your vehicle’s TPS, it is always recommended to seek professional help to avoid potential damage or safety hazards.

By following these troubleshooting suggestions and seeking professional assistance when necessary, you can effectively address and resolve any technical difficulties encountered during the TPS bypass process. This will help ensure a successful bypass and optimal engine performance.

Maintenance and Monitoring Post-Bypass

Importance of regularly monitoring engine performance after a TPS bypass

After successfully bypassing the throttle position sensor (TPS) and implementing any of the methods discussed, it is crucial to regularly monitor the engine’s performance to ensure optimal functioning. Monitoring engine performance post-bypass allows for early detection of any issues that may arise and allows for corrective measures to be taken.

Regular monitoring of engine performance can be done through the use of diagnostic tools and software that provide real-time data on various engine parameters. These tools can help identify any abnormalities or inconsistencies in the engine’s performance, such as irregular fuel consumption, abnormal throttle response, or engine misfires.

By monitoring engine performance, you can ensure that the TPS bypass has not negatively impacted other components or systems of the engine. It also allows you to assess the effectiveness of the bypass method chosen and make any necessary adjustments.

Recommendations for maintenance and fine-tuning post-bypass

To maintain and fine-tune the engine post-TPS bypass, several key maintenance and adjustment practices should be followed:

1. Regularly inspect and clean the throttle body: The throttle body can accumulate carbon deposits over time, affecting airflow and engine performance. Regularly cleaning the throttle body can help maintain smooth throttle response and prevent issues such as sticking or hesitation.

2. Perform regular engine tune-ups: Regular tune-ups, including spark plug replacement, fuel filter replacement, and air filter cleaning or replacement, can help optimize engine performance. These maintenance tasks are particularly important after a TPS bypass, as they ensure all components are functioning properly.

3. Monitor fuel consumption and adjust fuel mixture if necessary: An altered TPS signal may impact the fuel delivery system. Monitoring fuel consumption can help identify any irregularities and allow for adjustments to be made to the fuel mixture if needed.

4. Fine-tune throttle response: Depending on the bypass method implemented, the throttle response may need fine-tuning to achieve optimal performance. This can be done through adjusting the TPS settings or through other methods specific to the chosen bypass technique. Fine-tuning the throttle response ensures smooth acceleration and optimal engine power.

5. Periodic ECU recalibration: If the TPS bypass involved reprogramming the Engine Control Unit (ECU), periodically recalibrating the ECU may be necessary to maintain optimal engine performance. Consult the manufacturer’s documentation or seek professional assistance for correct recalibration procedures.

It is important to note that while bypassing the TPS can provide benefits in certain situations, it may not be legal or compliant with local regulations. Always ensure that any modifications made to the engine or its components are within the bounds of the law and adhere to local regulations.

Regular maintenance and monitoring following a TPS bypass help to identify and address any potential issues, ensuring the engine continues to perform optimally and safely. By taking these precautions, you can enjoy the benefits of the bypass while minimizing the risks associated with modified engine functionality.

Conclusion

A. Summary of TPS bypass methods and their respective pros and cons

In this guide, we have explored various methods to bypass the throttle position sensor (TPS) in order to overcome the restrictions and limitations it imposes on engine performance.

Firstly, we discussed the importance of understanding the TPS and its role in regulating engine performance. By adjusting the TPS settings within manufacturer limits, Method 1 provides a way to optimize engine performance without completely bypassing the sensor. This method offers potential improvements in throttle response and fuel efficiency. However, it is crucial to exercise caution and only make adjustments if you have the proper knowledge and experience.

If a more comprehensive bypass is needed, Method 2 involves installing a TPS bypass module. This device alters the signals sent to the engine control unit (ECU), effectively circumventing the TPS. While this method provides a complete bypass, it may come with potential drawbacks such as voiding warranties or triggering check engine lights.

Method 3 explores modifying the wiring connections of the TPS. By interrupting or adjusting the electrical signals, this method achieves a bypass without additional hardware. However, it requires technical expertise and may lead to irreversible damage if not done correctly.

Another option is Method 4, which involves reprogramming the ECU. This method allows for fine-tuning of the engine’s performance characteristics but requires the appropriate tools and equipment. It is important to consider the potential risks and legal implications associated with reprogramming the ECU.

B. Additional resources for further information on overcoming throttle position sensor restrictions

While this article provides a comprehensive guide on bypassing the throttle position sensor, it is important to conduct further research and consult additional resources for more in-depth knowledge.

For those interested in adjusting TPS settings, the manufacturer’s documentation or service manuals can provide specific guidelines for your particular vehicle model.

When considering the installation of a TPS bypass module, it is recommended to consult aftermarket automotive parts manufacturers or online forums dedicated to vehicle modifications for guidance and product recommendations.

For those considering modifying wiring connections or reprogramming the ECU, seeking professional advice from experienced automotive technicians or referring to specialized automotive forums can ensure the proper execution of these methods.

Always keep in mind that bypassing the throttle position sensor may have legal and ethical considerations. Local laws and regulations must be followed, and modifying or bypassing the TPS may have implications for vehicle warranty or emissions compliance.

In conclusion, bypassing the throttle position sensor can offer potential improvements in engine performance, but it requires careful consideration and expertise. By following the methods outlined in this guide and seeking further information from reliable resources, you can navigate the process of bypassing the TPS safely and effectively.

Leave a Comment