How Old Do You Have to Be to Buy a Lighter in Texas?

Buying a lighter may seem like a mundane task, yet regulations surrounding this seemingly innocuous item vary from state to state in the United States. Each region has its own set of laws dictating the minimum age required to purchase a lighter. In the state of Texas, where legal regulations often distinguish it from the rest of the country, the minimum age to buy a lighter stands as an interesting subject of discussion.

Texas, widely known for its proud heritage and independent spirit, has garnered a reputation for its distinctive laws and regulations. As one traverses the Lone Star State, it becomes evident that certain age restrictions set it apart. While some may assume that purchasing a lighter falls into the category of “trivial matters,” it is worthwhile to delve into how Texas governs the sale of lighters and safeguards its citizens, young and old, through state mandates.

Table of Contents

State Laws and Age Restrictions for Purchasing Lighters

A. Overview of state laws regarding age restrictions for lighters

In Texas, as in many other states, there are age restrictions in place for purchasing lighters. These laws are implemented to prevent minors from gaining access to potentially dangerous items and to promote public safety. Lighters are considered to be a fire hazard, and therefore, their sale to individuals under a certain age is regulated.

B. Legal age to purchase lighters without restrictions

In Texas, there is no specific age restriction for purchasing lighters without any restrictions. Unlike some states that have explicitly set a minimum age for lighter sales, Texas leaves it up to the discretion of the retailer. However, retailers are encouraged to exercise caution and to verify the age of the customer before selling lighters to avoid potential legal issues.

C. Common misconceptions about age requirements

There are several common misconceptions about age requirements for purchasing lighters in Texas. One misconception is that there is a statewide minimum age set by law, which is not the case. Another misconception is that anyone of any age can purchase lighters without any limitations, which is also not true. As mentioned earlier, although there is no specific age restriction set by the state, retailers may have their own policies regarding age requirements for purchasing lighters.

It is important for both consumers and retailers to be aware of these misconceptions and to understand that even without a specific age restriction in place, selling lighters to minors can still be seen as irresponsible and may have legal consequences.

Overall, while there may not be a specific age restriction for purchasing lighters in Texas, it is important for retailers to exercise caution and for consumers to be aware of any retailer policies in place. Ensuring that lighters do not fall into the hands of minors helps to promote public safety and prevent accidents or misuse. In the following sections, we will explore the various retailer policies regarding lighter sales, the connection between lighters and tobacco products, as well as the nationwide regulations and penalties for violating age restrictions.

Statewide Age Restrictions in Texas

A. Legal age to purchase lighters without restrictions

In Texas, there are no specific age restrictions for purchasing lighters. Unlike many other states that have implemented age restrictions for lighter sales, Texas allows individuals of all ages to purchase and possess lighters without any legal limitations. This means that both minors and adults can freely buy lighters in Texas without needing to provide identification or proof of age.

B. Common misconceptions about age requirements

Despite the absence of age restrictions in Texas, it is important to clarify some common misconceptions surrounding age requirements for purchasing lighters. Many people mistakenly believe that there is a minimum age limit set by the state or federal government. However, as mentioned earlier, Texas does not have any specific laws regarding the age at which someone can buy a lighter.

It is also worth noting that even though there are no legal restrictions on lighter sales, individual retailers may choose to enforce their own policies regarding age limits. Some stores may have company-wide regulations that require customers to be a certain age, such as 18 or 21, to purchase lighters. It is always advisable to check with the specific retailer before assuming their policies on lighter sales.

Additionally, while there are no age restrictions on purchasing lighters, it is essential to recognize that the use of lighters by minors can still be governed by other laws and regulations. For instance, if a minor uses a lighter to engage in illegal activities or cause harm, they may face legal consequences unrelated to the act of purchasing the lighter itself.

Overall, it is crucial to understand that while there are no state-set age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas, individual store policies may vary. It is advisable to respect and comply with any retailer regulations, especially if they enforce an age limit for lighter sales.

In the next section, we will delve into the policies set by retailers regarding lighter sales, including variations in their individual policies and the identification requirements that are commonly implemented.

IRetailer Policies Regarding Lighter Sales

A. Variations in retailer policies for selling lighters

In addition to state laws, retailers in Texas also have their own policies regarding the sale of lighters. While the legal age to purchase lighters without restrictions in Texas is 18, some retailers may choose to enforce stricter age requirements. This means that even if a person is of legal age, they may still be denied the purchase of a lighter if the retailer has set a higher age restriction.

It is important to note that these variations in retailer policies can be influenced by a number of factors. Some retailers may have company-wide policies that are implemented across all their stores, while others may leave the decision up to individual store managers. Additionally, the type of retailer can also impact their policies. For example, convenience stores and gas stations may have different age restrictions compared to specialty smoke shops.

B. Identification requirements for purchasing lighters

To ensure compliance with age restrictions, retailers may require individuals to provide valid identification when purchasing lighters. This is particularly common in cases where the retailer’s age restrictions are higher than the legal age limit. Acceptable forms of identification typically include government-issued photo IDs such as driver’s licenses or passports.

It is important for both retailers and consumers to be familiar with the identification requirements in order to avoid any confusion or potential legal issues. By adhering to these requirements, retailers can ensure that they are not selling lighters to underage individuals, while customers can ensure a smooth purchasing process by being prepared with the necessary identification.

By understanding the variations in retailer policies and the identification requirements for purchasing lighters, individuals can better navigate the process of buying lighters in Texas. It is crucial to comply with both state laws and retailer policies in order to avoid any penalties or consequences associated with violating age restrictions.

Tobacco Products and Age Restrictions

Lighters and tobacco products are closely related, as lighters are commonly used to ignite tobacco products such as cigarettes, cigars, and pipes. Therefore, it is important to consider the age restrictions for purchasing tobacco products when discussing the age requirements for lighters in Texas.

A. Connection between lighters and tobacco products

In Texas, the legal age to purchase tobacco products, including cigarettes and vaping devices, is 21 years old. This law was enacted in 2019 as part of the federal “Tobacco 21” legislation, which aimed to reduce youth access to tobacco products.

As lighters are often used in conjunction with tobacco products, it is essential to align the age restrictions for lighters with those for tobacco products. Purchasing a lighter at a younger age could potentially enable minors to have easier access to tobacco products.

B. Minimum age to purchase tobacco products in Texas

As mentioned earlier, the minimum age to buy tobacco products in Texas is 21 years old. This applies not only to cigarettes but also to other tobacco products such as chewing tobacco and electronic cigarettes.

It is worth noting that although some individuals may argue that lighters are not exclusively used for tobacco products and can have other purposes such as lighting candles or starting a fire for outdoor activities, the connection between lighters and tobacco products remains strong. Therefore, aligning the age restrictions for lighters with those for tobacco products is crucial in promoting responsible and legal use.

By setting the minimum age to purchase lighters in Texas at 21 years old, it ensures consistency with the age restrictions for tobacco products. This measure helps in preventing younger individuals from easily obtaining lighters and potentially accessing tobacco products illicitly.

Similarities and Differences with National Regulations

Age restrictions for lighters across different states

In Texas, laws regarding age restrictions for purchasing lighters are specific to the state. However, it is interesting to note that there are variations in age restrictions for lighters across different states in the United States.

While some states have implemented strict age requirements for purchasing lighters, others have more lenient regulations or have not specified any age restrictions at all. For example, California, New York, and New Jersey have set the legal age for purchasing lighters at 18, similar to Texas. On the other hand, states like Louisiana and Alaska do not have any specific age restrictions for purchasing lighters.

These variations in age restrictions highlight the differing approaches that states take when it comes to regulating the sale of lighters. Some argue that a uniform minimum age requirement should be established nationwide to avoid confusion and ensure consistency in enforcement. Others believe that age restrictions should be determined by individual states based on their unique circumstances and priorities.

Federal regulations on lighter sales

At the federal level, there are no specific regulations governing the sale of lighters based on age. The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) has not imposed any age restrictions for purchasing lighters. This means that age restrictions for lighters are primarily determined by state laws and individual retailer policies.

However, it is important to note that the federal government does regulate certain aspects of lighters to ensure consumer safety. The CPSC has established safety standards for lighters, such as child-resistant mechanisms, to prevent accidental fires and injuries. These regulations focus on the design and functionality of lighters rather than age restrictions for purchasing them.

In recent years, there have been discussions about the possibility of implementing federal age restrictions for lighters in line with tobacco purchasing regulations. Proponents argue that aligning age restrictions for lighters with those for tobacco products would create a consistent approach to youth access prevention. However, no federal legislation has been enacted to date.

Overall, while federal regulations primarily focus on product safety, age restrictions for purchasing lighters are largely determined by state laws and individual retailer policies. The lack of uniformity in age restrictions across states raises questions about the effectiveness and enforcement of such regulations. As the debate continues, it remains important to be aware of the specific age restrictions in one’s own state, such as Texas, to ensure compliance with the law.

Penalties for Violating Age Restrictions

A. Consequences for both the retailer and the buyer

In Texas, violating age restrictions for purchasing lighters can result in serious consequences for both the retailer and the buyer. Retailers who sell lighters to underage individuals can face penalties such as fines or the suspension or revocation of their sales license. These penalties are intended to hold retailers accountable for ensuring that age restrictions are followed.

Retailers found guilty of selling lighters to minors can be fined up to $500 for a first offense and up to $1,000 for subsequent violations. In addition to monetary penalties, retailers may also face suspension or revocation of their sales license, depending on the severity and frequency of offenses. These penalties serve as a deterrent for retailers to strictly adhere to age restrictions and exercise due diligence in verifying the age of customers.

On the other hand, underage individuals who attempt to purchase lighters can also face penalties. While the consequences for buyers may not be as severe as those for retailers, there can still be legal ramifications. Texas law considers it a Class C misdemeanor for a minor to possess a cigarette lighter. If caught in possession of a lighter, a minor could be subject to fines or other legal penalties.

B. Enforcement of age requirements

The enforcement of age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas falls primarily to local law enforcement agencies, such as the police or the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC). These agencies conduct periodic sting operations where they send underage individuals into retail establishments to attempt to purchase age-restricted products, including lighters. If a retailer fails to comply with age restrictions during these operations, they may be cited or face legal consequences.

In addition to these enforcement efforts, retailers themselves play a crucial role in upholding age requirements. Many reputable retailers have implemented training programs for their employees to ensure they are knowledgeable about age restrictions and properly check identification before selling lighters. By engaging in responsible sales practices and training their staff, retailers can actively contribute to the enforcement of age restrictions.

It is important for both retailers and buyers to be aware of the potential penalties for violating age restrictions for purchasing lighters. By understanding and complying with these regulations, retailers can avoid legal consequences, and buyers can avoid potential legal trouble. Ultimately, the enforcement of age requirements not only helps protect young individuals from potential harm but also promotes responsible and compliant business practices within the retail industry.

Advocacy and Awareness Programs

Organizations promoting awareness of age restrictions for lighters

In order to ensure compliance with age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas, several organizations have emerged to advocate for awareness and education.

One such organization is the Texas Association of Retailers (TAR), which actively promotes the importance of age restrictions for lighter sales. TAR works closely with retailers across the state, providing them with necessary information and resources to ensure compliance with the law. They emphasize the importance of verifying the age of customers and making sure that lighters are only sold to individuals who meet the legal requirements.

Another organization that promotes awareness of age restrictions for lighters is the Texas Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids (TCTFK). While their primary focus is on tobacco products, they recognize the connection between lighters and smoking-related activities. TCTFK conducts educational campaigns targeting both retailers and consumers, raising awareness about age restrictions and emphasizing the importance of responsible sales practices. They also provide resources and materials to retailers to aid in compliance.

Educational campaigns targeting retailers and consumers

Educational campaigns play a crucial role in spreading awareness and promoting compliance with age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas. These campaigns target both retailers and consumers, aiming to ensure a comprehensive understanding of the legal requirements.

For retailers, educational campaigns focus on the significance of accurately verifying customers’ ages and training employees to enforce age restrictions. They provide information on proper identification procedures and emphasize the potential legal consequences of non-compliance. By educating retailers, these campaigns strive to create a responsible sales environment that prioritizes age restrictions.

Consumer-focused campaigns aim to inform the public about the age requirements for purchasing lighters. These campaigns utilize various platforms, such as social media, informational websites, and local community outreach events, to reach a wide audience. The goal is to ensure that consumers are aware of the age restrictions and understand the need for compliance. By targeting consumers, these campaigns aim to generate increased public support for age restrictions and foster a community-wide commitment to responsible lighter sales.

Through their efforts, advocacy and awareness programs in Texas are working towards a society that is well-informed about age restrictions for purchasing lighters. By collaborating with retailers and educating both sellers and buyers, these programs play a critical role in promoting compliance and reducing underage access to lighters throughout the state.

Arguments for and against Age Restrictions

A. Arguments supporting age restrictions for lighters

Age restrictions for purchasing lighters are implemented with the intention of promoting safety and responsible use. Proponents of age restrictions argue that lighters can be dangerous if misused, especially by minors. By setting a minimum age requirement, it is believed that young individuals are less likely to engage in risky behavior such as playing with fire or starting fires intentionally.

Another argument supporting age restrictions is the connection between lighters and tobacco use. Many states, including Texas, have established a minimum age for purchasing tobacco products to prevent underage smoking. Lighters are commonly associated with smoking and are often used as a tool to ignite cigarettes, cigars, and other tobacco products. Age restrictions for lighters align with these regulations and reinforce the larger effort to deter underage smoking.

Furthermore, implementing age restrictions for lighters can help discourage youth experimentation with illicit substances. Lighters are frequently used to heat drug paraphernalia, such as pipes or foil, before inhaling illicit substances. By restricting access to lighters, it becomes more difficult for young individuals to engage in drug-related activities, thereby reducing potential harms.

B. Counterarguments against age restrictions

Critics of age restrictions for lighters may argue that it infringes upon personal freedoms and does not effectively address the issue at hand. They claim that age restrictions are unnecessary since lighters are everyday items with multiple practical uses beyond smoking or drug-related activities. Restricting access to lighters based on age may unfairly penalize responsible individuals who use lighters for legitimate purposes, such as lighting candles or starting campfires.

Another counterargument is that age restrictions for lighters may not be enforceable, leading to inconsistent implementation and ineffective policy outcomes. Critics argue that it is challenging for retailers to accurately determine the buyer’s age solely based on appearance, especially when no other restrictive items, such as tobacco, are being purchased. This raises concerns about potential discrimination and inconveniences faced by individuals who are of legal age but are denied lighter purchases due to their appearance.

Additionally, opponents of age restrictions may question the effectiveness of such regulations in actually preventing misuse or dangerous behaviors. They argue that individuals who are determined to engage in risky behavior, such as playing with fire, will find alternative methods regardless of age restrictions. Instead, they propose education and awareness campaigns to promote responsible lighter use as a more effective approach.

Overall, the arguments for and against age restrictions for lighters in Texas highlight the tension between public safety concerns and personal freedom. While proponents argue that age restrictions can mitigate potential harm, critics raise concerns about the practicality and effectiveness of such regulations.

Public Opinion and Perceptions

A. Public opinion on age restrictions for purchasing lighters

Public opinion on age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas is divided. Supporters of age restrictions argue that it is necessary to prevent minors from accessing potentially dangerous items. They believe that lighters can pose risks, such as accidental fires or misuse, when in the hands of young individuals who may not fully understand the consequences of their actions. They argue that setting an age requirement helps to limit the availability of lighters to responsible adults who can not only use them safely but also monitor their use by younger family members.

Opponents of age restrictions argue that they are unnecessary and infringe upon personal freedom. They believe that the responsibility lies with parents and guardians to educate and monitor their children’s access to potentially dangerous items. They argue that age restrictions unfairly penalize adults who may need lighters for legitimate purposes, such as lighting candles or starting a barbecue, and impede their convenience by creating unnecessary hurdles for the purchase of a commonly used item.

B. Cultural factors influencing perceptions on lighter sales

Cultural factors also play a role in shaping perceptions on lighter sales. In Texas, a state known for its independent spirit and emphasis on personal freedom, there is a cultural mindset that values individual liberties and minimal government intervention. This cultural perspective can contribute to the opposition against age restrictions, as it aligns with the belief in personal responsibility and limited government regulation.

On the other hand, there are cultural norms that prioritize safety and protection, especially when it comes to children and minors. Concern for the well-being and security of young individuals may influence some individuals to support age restrictions for purchasing lighters. They may perceive such restrictions as a means to ensure the safety of minors and prevent potential harm or accidents.

It is essential to recognize and navigate these cultural factors when discussing and implementing regulations related to age restrictions for lighters. Public opinion and cultural considerations should be taken into account to strike a balance between protecting the welfare of minors and respecting individuals’ freedoms and cultural values.

Overall, public opinion in Texas regarding age restrictions for purchasing lighters is diverse, reflecting a range of perspectives based on personal values, beliefs, and cultural influences. The ongoing discussion surrounding this topic highlights the importance of considering public sentiment when shaping policies that impact access to lighters in the state.

Effectiveness of Age Restrictions

A. Research on the effectiveness of age restrictions for lighters

Age restrictions on the purchase of lighters have been implemented in many states, including Texas, in order to reduce the risk of fire-related incidents caused by underage individuals. Several studies and research have been conducted to determine the effectiveness of these restrictions.

Research has shown that age restrictions on lighter sales can be effective in limiting access to lighters by minors. A study conducted by the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) found that states with age restrictions reported a decrease in fire-related incidents caused by underage individuals. Restricting access to lighters can help prevent accidental fires and other potentially dangerous situations.

Another study conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) focused on the impact of age restrictions on smoking rates among youth. The study found that states with stricter age restrictions on purchasing tobacco products, including lighters, had lower smoking rates among youth compared to states with less strict regulations. This suggests that age restrictions for lighters can also have a positive impact on reducing smoking initiation among young people.

B. Success stories from states with strict age requirements

Several states that have implemented strict age requirements for purchasing lighters have seen positive results in terms of reducing fire-related incidents and protecting youth from potentially harmful situations.

For example, New York implemented a law that raised the minimum age for purchasing lighters to 21. Since the implementation of this law, there has been a noticeable decrease in fire-related incidents caused by minors. This success story from New York demonstrates the potential effectiveness of strict age restrictions on lighter sales.

Similarly, California implemented a law that requires all retailers to verify the age of customers purchasing lighters. This regulation has led to increased compliance among retailers and a reduction in underage individuals gaining access to lighters. The success of California’s regulations further supports the effectiveness of age restrictions in preventing dangerous situations.

Overall, research and success stories from states with strict age requirements for purchasing lighters provide evidence of the effectiveness of these restrictions. Implementing and enforcing age restrictions can help protect youth and reduce fire-related incidents caused by underage individuals. These findings encourage the importance of complying with age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas and highlight the potential for future changes and discussions regarding stricter regulations.

Proposed Changes and Future Discussions

A. Calls for stricter regulations regarding lighter sales

In recent years, there have been increasing calls for stricter regulations regarding the sale of lighters in Texas. Advocacy groups and public health organizations argue that current age restrictions are not effectively preventing minors from accessing lighters. They contend that stricter regulations are necessary to protect young people from the potential dangers associated with the use of lighters and prevent them from engaging in risky behaviors.

Proponents of stricter regulations propose implementing a unified statewide age restriction for purchasing lighters. This would eliminate any confusion caused by variations in retailer policies and ensure consistency across the state. They argue that a higher minimum age requirement, such as 21 years old, would be more effective in preventing underage usage and curb teenage experimentation with fire-related activities.

Additionally, some advocates suggest exploring additional restrictions on the design and marketing of lighters. They argue that certain novelty lighters, which resemble toys or have attractive designs, may be particularly appealing to young children and could increase the likelihood of accidents or misuse. Stricter regulations in this regard would aim to prevent access and reduce the appeal of lighters to minors.

B. Potential changes in age restrictions for lighters

While no immediate changes have been made to the age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas, there is ongoing discussion about potential revisions to the current regulations. Lawmakers are considering proposals to raise the minimum age for purchasing lighters to align with the legal age for tobacco product purchases, which is currently set at 21 years old.

Proponents of this change argue that there is a logical connection between lighters and tobacco products since lighters are often used to ignite cigarettes or other tobacco-related items. They believe that aligning the age restrictions for lighters and tobacco would create a cohesive approach to youth access prevention and promote a consistent message regarding the potential risks associated with smoking and fire-related activities.

However, opponents of such changes argue that lighters serve various purposes beyond just lighting tobacco products. They contend that lighters are common household items used for practical purposes such as lighting candles, starting fire pits or grills, and other non-related tobacco activities. They argue that restricting access to lighters based on tobacco regulations may be unnecessary and overly burdensome for adult consumers who use lighters for non-tobacco purposes.

As discussions continue, it is essential for stakeholders to consider the potential impact of proposed changes on both public safety and individual liberty. Striking a balance between preventing underage usage and maintaining adults’ access to lighters for legitimate purposes will be crucial in shaping future regulations regarding lighter sales in Texas.

Conclusion

A. Summary of key points discussed

In this article, we have explored the importance of knowing age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas. We examined the state laws and age restrictions for purchasing lighters, including common misconceptions. We also discussed retailer policies, the connection between lighters and tobacco products, and similarities and differences with national regulations. Additionally, we examined penalties for violating age restrictions, advocacy and awareness programs, arguments for and against age restrictions, and public opinion and perceptions. We delved into the effectiveness of age restrictions, research findings, and success stories. Furthermore, we discussed proposed changes and future discussions regarding stricter regulations and potential revisions to age restrictions for lighters.

B. Importance of complying with age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas

Complying with age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas is crucial to ensure the safety of young people and prevent potentially harmful incidents. The use of lighters by minors can lead to accidents, injuries, and even fires. By adhering to age restrictions, retailers play a vital role in preventing underage usage and promoting responsible access to lighters. Furthermore, individuals should be aware of age requirements when purchasing lighters, as it is their responsibility to follow the law and consider the potential risks associated with underage usage.

By understanding the current regulations and engaging in discussions about potential changes, Texas can create a comprehensive approach to lighters’ sales that balances public safety concerns with individual rights. Stricter regulations and revisions to the age restrictions for lighters may be necessary to effectively prevent underage usage and ensure the well-being of young people in the state. It is through informed discussions and collaborative efforts that Texas can shape future policies surrounding the sale of lighters and protect its residents, particularly its youth, from potential harm.

Conclusion

A. Summary of key points discussed

Throughout this article, we have explored the age restrictions and regulations surrounding the purchase of lighters in Texas. We have learned that while there are no specific age restrictions set by the state, retailers have the discretion to enforce their own policies. This can lead to confusion and misconceptions about the legal age to purchase lighters in Texas.

We have also examined the connection between lighters and tobacco products, as well as the minimum age to purchase tobacco products in Texas. Although the legal age for purchasing tobacco products is 21, this does not necessarily apply to lighters. It is important to distinguish between the two and not assume that the age restrictions for one automatically apply to the other.

In comparison to national regulations, we have found that age restrictions for lighters vary across different states, and there are also federal regulations in place. These regulations, however, focus more on child-resistant packaging and safety requirements rather than age restrictions. Therefore, it is crucial for both retailers and consumers to be aware of the specific regulations in their state regarding lighter sales.

B. Importance of complying with age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas

Complying with age restrictions for purchasing lighters in Texas is crucial for several reasons. First and foremost, it helps prevent minors from accessing potentially dangerous objects and using them irresponsibly. Lighters can be hazardous if misused, and by enforcing age restrictions, it ensures that these items are kept out of the hands of those who may not fully understand the risks associated with them.

Furthermore, complying with age restrictions can help retailers avoid legal consequences. Violating age restrictions for lighter sales can result in penalties and fines, both for the retailer and the buyer. By properly adhering to the age requirements, retailers can protect their businesses and maintain a positive reputation within their communities.

Lastly, complying with age restrictions for purchasing lighters showcases a commitment to responsible retail practices. By actively preventing underage individuals from purchasing lighters, retailers demonstrate their dedication to the well-being and safety of their customers. This can foster trust and loyalty among both consumers and the broader community.

In conclusion, while Texas does not have a specific age restriction for purchasing lighters, it is vital for retailers and consumers to be aware of individual retailer policies and to exercise responsible purchasing practices. By understanding the connection between lighters and tobacco products, complying with age restrictions, and advocating for awareness, we can ensure the safe and responsible sale of lighters in Texas.

Leave a Comment