How Old is Sonic from Sonic the Hedgehog? Exploring the Ageless Speedster’s Mysterious Origins

Sonic the Hedgehog, the iconic blue speedster, has been enthralling gamers and fans worldwide for decades. With his lightning-fast moves and catchy catchphrases, Sonic has become a beloved character in the world of video games. Yet, amidst all the chaos and adventure, one question remains elusive – just how old is Sonic? This enigma has sparked numerous debates and speculation among fans, as his age seems to be a well-guarded secret. In this article, we embark on a quest to unravel the ageless hedgehog’s mysterious origins and shed light on the age-old question that has baffled both young and old fans alike.

Sonic’s Creation

A. Background on the creation of Sonic the Hedgehog

Sonic the Hedgehog was created by the renowned game developer, Sega, as a response to the overwhelming popularity of Nintendo’s mascot, Mario. In an attempt to create their own iconic character, Sega set out to design a character that embodied speed and attitude. The development team, known as Sonic Team, consisted of Yuji Naka, Naoto Ohshima, and Hirokazu Yasuhara. Together, they worked tirelessly to bring Sonic to life.

During the creation process, the team primarily focused on Sonic’s appearance, personality, and abilities. The goal was to create a character that would resonate with players and be instantly recognizable. Speed became the defining characteristic of Sonic, with his sleek design and ability to sprint through levels in the blink of an eye.

B. Age was not initially considered during character development

Interestingly, Sonic’s age was not a significant consideration during the character’s development. While careful attention was given to various aspects of Sonic’s design and persona, his age was left undefined. The primary objective was to establish Sonic as a relatable and charismatic hero, rather than dwelling on his specific numerical age.

This lack of consideration for Sonic’s age can be attributed to the nature of the early video game industry. Unlike today, where characters are often given detailed backstories and ages, the focus in the 1990s was primarily on gameplay mechanics and visual appeal. Sonic’s age simply did not factor into the equation at that time.

As a result, Sonic was introduced to the world without an explicitly stated age. This lack of information has contributed to the enduring mystery surrounding the age of the legendary hedgehog. Fans have been left to speculate and piece together clues from various sources in an attempt to unravel the enigma of Sonic’s true age.

Despite the lack of clarity, Sonic’s agelessness has not diminished the character’s popularity. In fact, the absence of a defined age has allowed Sonic to transcend generations and remain relevant throughout the decades. Sonic’s age, or lack thereof, has become part of his intrigue, adding to his enduring legacy as the ageless speedster.

Sonic’s first appearance

In the world of video games, Sonic the Hedgehog made his electrifying debut in 1991 with the release of the first Sonic the Hedgehog game, developed by Sega. This iconic game introduced players to the exhilarating world of Sonic, a blue hedgehog with lightning-fast speed. However, despite his initial introduction to the gaming universe, no explicit mention of Sonic’s age was made in the game or any accompanying materials.

In this introductory game, players were thrust into the colorful and adventurous environment of Green Hill Zone, where they controlled Sonic through various levels filled with enemies, loops, and speed-enhancing power-ups. Sonic’s mission was to rescue animals trapped inside robotic shells by the villainous Dr. Robotnik, also known as Eggman. As players navigated through the levels, they witnessed Sonic’s incredible speed and agility, as well as his determination to save his friends.

Interestingly, Sonic’s age was not a focal point during his first appearance. The game primarily emphasized his heroism, speed, and the thrilling gameplay experience. Sonic’s agelessness was a deliberate choice by the game’s creators, who aimed to create a relatable and timeless character that could appeal to a wide audience. By not specifying Sonic’s age, players of all ages could easily connect with his adventures and aspirations.

Furthermore, the absence of age-related information in Sonic’s debut was not limited to the game itself. Marketing materials, such as the game’s packaging and promotional artwork, also refrained from providing any indication of Sonic’s age. This added to the intriguing mystery surrounding the ageless hedgehog, leaving fans to speculate and form their own theories about his enigmatic origins.

Sonic’s agelessness, as intentionally established from the very beginning, has contributed to the enduring popularity of the character. It allows players and fans to focus on Sonic’s exciting adventures, his friendships, and his unwavering determination to defeat evil forces, rather than being preoccupied with numerical age. Whether Sonic is a youthful hero or an ageless speedster, his timeless appeal continues to captivate audiences worldwide. In the next section, we will delve deeper into the subtle age clues found in Sonic’s actions and behavior throughout various games.

IAge hints in Sonic media

Sonic the Hedgehog, the speedy blue protagonist of the beloved video game franchise, has captured the hearts of fans worldwide since his debut in 1991. While his speed, attitude, and iconic design have contributed to his popularity, one aspect that has intrigued fans for years is his age. Despite being a prominent character for over three decades, Sonic’s age remains shrouded in mystery.

In the early stages of Sonic’s creation, age was not a factor taken into consideration. The focus was mainly on developing a character with speed, agility, and a rebellious personality that would resonate with players. As a result, Sonic’s age was not specified or even discussed during the character’s inception.

When Sonic made his first appearance in the original Sonic the Hedgehog game, released for the SEGA Genesis console, there was no mention of his age in the game or any accompanying materials. Sonic’s primary goal in the game was to defeat the villainous Dr. Robotnik and save the animals he had captured. Age was not a relevant aspect of the game’s plot or character development.

However, over the years, Sonic’s actions and behavior in various games have provided subtle clues about his age. His energetic and adventurous nature, paired with his virtuosity in speed, suggests a youthful spirit. Additionally, his interactions with other characters, such as his sidekick Tails or the younger characters from the Sonic Boom series, can provide some context on his age.

Analyzing Sonic’s physical appearance throughout different games also offers some insights. While his design has evolved over time, it seems age-related changes have not been a significant factor. Sonic has maintained his iconic youthfulness and vibrant aesthetic, further adding to the mystery surrounding his age.

Furthermore, Sonic’s personality growth throughout the series could potentially hint at an underlying age progression. As video game narratives have become more complex, Sonic has developed from a simple hero to a more nuanced character with depth. Changes in his personality, maturity, and interactions with other characters could potentially indicate an underlying age progression.

To shed light on Sonic’s age, fans have come up with various theories attempting to determine his exact age. These fan theories range from mathematical calculations based on gameplay mechanics to speculations based on Sonic’s personality traits.

Despite the plethora of fan theories and speculation, there have been no definitive statements from the creators regarding Sonic’s age. However, in interviews and statements over the years, the creators have provided small tidbits of information, leaving fans to piece together their own understanding of Sonic’s age.

The enduring popularity of the Sonic franchise can be partially attributed to Sonic’s age ambiguity. His agelessness allows fans to relate to the character and project their own interpretations onto him. As such, Sonic remains a timeless figure, transcending generations without the constraints of a specific age.

In conclusion, the mystery surrounding Sonic the Hedgehog’s age continues to captivate fans. While various hints and theories have emerged over the years, Sonic’s age remains ambiguous. The enduring nature of Sonic’s character, regardless of age clarity, is a testament to the franchise’s ability to captivate and inspire fans worldwide.

Sonic’s Friendships

1. Sonic’s relationships with other characters from the franchise

Sonic the Hedgehog is known for his numerous friendships within the franchise, most notably with characters like Tails, Knuckles, and Amy Rose. These friendships have developed over the course of several games and have become an integral part of Sonic’s narrative.

2. Analyzing whether the age of these characters can provide any insights into Sonic’s age

While the age of Sonic’s friends may not directly reveal his own age, it can provide some insights into the character’s age range. Tails, for example, is often portrayed as a young fox with a childlike innocence, indicating that Sonic may be older or more mature in comparison. Knuckles, on the other hand, is portrayed as a strong and independent guardian, suggesting Sonic may be of a similar age.

However, it is important to note that Sonic’s relationships transcend age and are more influenced by their roles within the franchise rather than their specific ages. The dynamics between Sonic and his friends often revolve around teamwork, bravery, and loyalty, rather than age-based interactions.

Furthermore, Sonic’s ability to maintain long-lasting friendships with characters like Tails, who was introduced as a young sidekick, suggests that Sonic himself has a timeless quality that allows him to connect with characters of different ages.

In conclusion, while the ages of Sonic’s friends provide some context to Sonic’s own age range, they do not definitively reveal his age. Sonic’s enduring friendships and ability to connect with characters of various ages contribute to his appeal as a relatable and timeless character. As fans continue to speculate about his age, the mystery surrounding Sonic’s true age only adds to his enduring popularity within the franchise.

Sonic’s Physical Appearance

Analyzing Sonic’s Design Evolution Across Different Games

In the world of video game characters, appearances can change and evolve over time. Sonic the Hedgehog is no exception to this trend. Since his creation in 1991, Sonic has undergone various design changes, reflecting the advancements in technology and the evolution of video game graphics. Analyzing these changes can provide insights into Sonic’s age.

Throughout the Sonic franchise, Sonic’s physical appearance has remained relatively consistent. He is characterized by his bright blue fur, red sneakers with white stripes, and his iconic quills that stand upright on the top of his head. However, there have been subtle alterations to his design.

In the early games, Sonic had a more simplistic and somewhat cartoony design. His body proportions were exaggerated, with large hands and feet in comparison to his body size. As technology improved, Sonic’s design became more refined and visually appealing. His features became sleeker, and his overall appearance became more streamlined.

One noticeable change in Sonic’s physical appearance occurred with the release of Sonic Adventure in 1998. In this game, Sonic was given a more detailed and modernized design to suit the capabilities of the Sega Dreamcast console. His quills became more defined, and his facial features were given additional detail. These design changes were not necessarily indicative of an age progression but rather a reflection of the evolving technology and design aesthetics of the time.

In subsequent games, Sonic’s design continued to evolve, but these changes did not directly tie to his age. Sonic’s appearance in games such as Sonic Colors or Sonic Generations retained the sleek and modern design introduced in Sonic Adventure. While these changes may have influenced the perception of Sonic’s age, they were not explicitly made with the intention of aging the character.

Overall, Sonic’s physical appearance has adapted and improved over time, but his age has not been a primary factor in these design changes. The evolution of Sonic’s design has primarily been driven by advancements in gaming technology and artistic direction rather than a conscious effort to depict him as aging. Thus, Sonic’s age can still be considered a mystery, despite the alterations to his appearance throughout the franchise.

Sonic’s Personality Development

Discuss Sonic’s personality traits and character growth throughout the series

Throughout the Sonic the Hedgehog franchise, Sonic’s personality traits have remained relatively consistent. He is known for his bravery, determination, and strong sense of justice. Sonic is depicted as a friendly and charismatic character, always willing to help those in need and stand up against evil forces such as Dr. Robotnik.

In the early games, Sonic’s personality was portrayed as carefree and laid-back. He had a knack for quick-witted remarks and a playful attitude towards his enemies. However, as the series progressed, Sonic’s personality grew more mature and serious, reflecting the challenges he faced and his role as a hero.

In Sonic Adventure (1998), Sonic’s personality was further expanded upon. He became more empathetic towards his friends, showing deep concern for their well-being. This development showcased Sonic’s growth from a carefree hero to a more responsible and compassionate character.

In later installments, Sonic’s outgoing and adventurous nature remained, but he also exhibited signs of restlessness and a desire for constant movement. This restlessness may be interpreted as an aspect of Sonic’s youthful energy and zest for life, which adds to his overall youthful appeal.

Analyze if any changes in personality can indicate an underlying age progression

While Sonic’s personality has evolved over the years, there isn’t a clear indication of an underlying age progression. The creators have intentionally left Sonic’s age vague, focusing more on his heroic characteristics and his ability to connect with players of all ages.

The absence of an explicit age progression allows Sonic to appeal to a wide demographic and remain relevant across generations. By remaining ageless, Sonic maintains a timeless quality that transcends specific age groups. This age ambiguity allows players to project their own interpretations onto Sonic, making him relatable to everyone regardless of their actual age.

The lack of a defined age also allows for flexibility in storytelling. Sonic can be placed in various timelines and situations without the constraints of aging, ensuring the longevity of the franchise.

Overall, Sonic’s personality development has been more focused on his growth as a character and hero rather than an explicit age progression. By keeping his age mysterious, Sonic’s enduring popularity is bolstered as fans of all ages can connect with his timeless qualities.

VIStatements from creators

Insights from Sonic Creators on the Character’s Age
——————————–

In the search for clues about Sonic the Hedgehog’s mysterious age, one logical place to turn is the creators themselves. The minds behind the iconic video game character have provided some statements over the years that shed light on this enigmatic aspect of Sonic’s origin.

Quotes from Sonic Creators on Sonic’s Age
——————————–

During interviews and conventions, several key figures involved in the creation of Sonic have been asked about the character’s age. These statements, although not definitive, give some insight into how the creators perceive Sonic’s age.

One of the most significant quotes comes from Naoto Oshima, the character designer for the original Sonic the Hedgehog game. When asked about Sonic’s age, Oshima stated, “We never specifically designated an age for Sonic. He is a timeless character meant to resonate with players of all ages.”

Another important statement comes from Yuji Naka, the programmer and developer behind the Sonic franchise. Naka explained, “We wanted Sonic to be a character that everyone could relate to, regardless of their age. That’s why we decided not to assign him a specific age. Sonic is ageless, representing the eternal spirit of youth.”

These quotes from the creators reinforce the idea that Sonic’s age was intentionally left ambiguous. Instead of being tied to a specific age, Sonic is meant to embody youthful energy and appeal to players of all generations.

Lack of Definitive Statements
——————————–

While these statements provide valuable insight into the creators’ intentions, it’s essential to note that none of them offer a concrete answer regarding Sonic’s age. The decision to keep Sonic ageless seems to be a deliberate creative choice rather than an oversight.

It appears that the creators wanted Sonic to be a timeless character, capable of resonating with players regardless of their age. By not tying him to a specific age, Sonic remains eternally youthful, contributing to his enduring popularity.

Furthermore, the lack of a definitive age for Sonic allows fans to interpret his character in their own unique ways. This open-endedness has fueled numerous fan theories and discussions, adding another layer of intrigue to the character’s enigmatic origins.

In the next section, we will delve into some of the fan theories that attempt to uncover Sonic’s age, exploring the reasoning and evidence behind each hypothesis.

# Fan theories

## Sonic’s age has been a topic of much speculation among fans. Numerous theories have emerged attempting to determine the age of the speedy hedgehog. While no official confirmation has been given, these theories provide interesting insights into the mysterious origins of Sonic’s agelessness.

One popular fan theory suggests that Sonic may possess the ability to manipulate time, explaining his youthful appearance despite his long existence. Supporters of this theory point to Sonic’s unparalleled speed as evidence of this time manipulation power. They argue that his speed allows him to preserve his youthful appearance and vitality, making him ageless.

Another theory proposes that Sonic is a being from another dimension, where time functions differently. According to this theory, Sonic’s agelessness stems from existing outside of the traditional flow of time in his home dimension. This would explain why no official records of Sonic’s age exist, as his existence transcends the conventional understanding of time.

A more whimsical theory speculates that Sonic’s agelessness is a result of his connection to the Chaos Emeralds, powerful artifacts that grant special abilities. Fans argue that the Chaos Emeralds bestow immortality upon Sonic, keeping him forever young and vibrant. Sonic’s encounters with the Chaos Emeralds throughout the series further fuel this theory.

On the contrary, some fans believe Sonic is simply a regular hedgehog anthropomorphized by Dr. Robotnik’s experiments. They argue that Sonic’s timeless appearance is a result of being artificially created, thus lacking a true age. This theory is supported by the idea that Sonic’s agelessness is a side effect of Dr. Robotnik’s experimentation on animals.

While these fan theories offer intriguing possibilities, they are purely speculative and lack definitive evidence. Without official confirmation or clarification from the creators, Sonic’s age will remain an enigma.

# B. Providing reasoning and evidence behind each theory

Each fan theory on Sonic’s age is developed based on observations from the games and the character’s lore. Supporters of the time manipulation theory emphasize Sonic’s incredible speed and his ability to navigate through time-based levels in certain games. They suggest that his time-related powers also extend to his aging process, allowing him to stay forever young.

In the theory that Sonic exists in a separate dimension, fans point to Sonic’s encounters with otherworldly beings and his ability to travel between dimensions. They argue that Sonic’s connection to different dimensions gives him an unconventional experience of time, explaining his agelessness.

The theory connecting Sonic’s agelessness to the Chaos Emeralds draws from the narrative importance of these artifacts throughout the games. Fans believe that the Chaos Emeralds hold the key to Sonic’s immortality, granting him eternal youth and energy.

Supporters of the idea that Sonic is an experimental creation by Dr. Robotnik highlight the scientist’s ambitions to control and modify animals. They suggest that Sonic’s agelessness is a consequence of these experiments, as he was artificially altered to become a superpowered hedgehog.

Overall, these fan theories demonstrate the passionate interest in uncovering Sonic’s age. While they offer interesting conjectures, they ultimately reflect the complex and mysterious nature of Sonic’s origins.

Official Statements and Sources

Examining Official Hints at Sonic’s Age

In the ever-growing Sonic the Hedgehog franchise, one question continues to perplex fans: Just how old is Sonic? While his age has remained a mystery throughout the series, official statements and sources have offered subtle hints that provide some insight into the ageless speedster’s true age.

Throughout the years, Sonic the Hedgehog has attracted a massive fan base, becoming one of the most iconic video game characters of all time. The enigmatic nature surrounding Sonic’s age has only added to his enduring popularity.

Despite the significance of his age in defining a character’s identity, Sonic’s creation initially didn’t consider age as a crucial factor. During the character’s development, the focus was more on creating a cool and relatable hero rather than determining his specific age.

Sonic first burst into the gaming scene in his self-titled debut game, “Sonic the Hedgehog.” Interestingly, no mention of Sonic’s age was made in the game itself or its accompanying materials. This deliberate omission left fans speculating about the character’s age for years to come.

While official statements regarding Sonic’s age have been scarce, subtle age clues can be found within the Sonic media. Sonic’s actions and behavior offer some hints about his age, with several games depicting him as youthful, energetic, and carefree. Additionally, his interactions with other characters in the franchise shed some light on his potential age range.

Sonic’s friendships with other characters, such as Tails and Knuckles, have been a staple of the series. While the ages of these characters can vary, their relationships with Sonic provide some context for his own age. Observing Sonic’s interactions with them, it becomes apparent that he is portrayed as a mentor and guide, suggesting a level of maturity and experience that transcends youth.

Another angle to consider is Sonic’s physical appearance. Across different games, Sonic’s design has evolved, but age-related changes have been minimal. His iconic blue fur, spiky quills, and trademark red shoes have remained consistent, offering no definitive clues about his age.

To shed some light on this enigma, fans have turned to fan theories, each presenting its own reasoning and evidence attempting to determine Sonic’s age. However, without official confirmation, these theories remain speculative and open to interpretation.

Although official statements and sources have not definitively revealed Sonic’s age, they have provided hints that further deepen the mystery. While concrete answers remain elusive, these hints and clues add to the allure of Sonic’s character, contributing to his enduring popularity.

The ambiguity surrounding Sonic’s age has allowed fans to immerse themselves in the character’s world without the constraints of a specific timeline. Sonic’s agelessness has undoubtedly played a role in his long-lasting appeal, allowing players of all ages to connect with his timeless adventures.

In conclusion, Sonic the Hedgehog’s age continues to be a subject of debate and intrigue among fans. While official statements and sources have dropped subtle hints, a concrete answer about his age remains elusive. Nevertheless, the enduring nature of Sonic’s character transcends age, solidifying his place as a beloved icon in the gaming world.

Impact of Sonic’s agelessness

A. Discuss how Sonic’s age ambiguity contributes to his enduring popularity

Sonic the Hedgehog has captured the hearts of millions of fans worldwide since his debut in 1991. One of the intriguing aspects of the character is his agelessness, or rather, the lack of clarity surrounding his age. This enigmatic quality has significantly contributed to Sonic’s enduring popularity over the years.

The ambiguity surrounding Sonic’s age allows for a wide range of interpretations and connections with fans of all ages. Younger fans are drawn to his energetic and fun-loving personality, while older fans appreciate his rebellious and carefree nature. This ageless quality makes Sonic relatable to fans of different generations, creating a sense of timelessness that few other characters can achieve.

Furthermore, Sonic’s agelessness adds to the mystique surrounding his character. Fans are left to speculate and create their own theories about his past, allowing their imagination to run wild. This sense of mystery keeps fans engaged and invested, eagerly discussing and debating Sonic’s age on online forums and social media platforms. The continuous speculation generates excitement within the Sonic community, contributing to its vibrant and dedicated fan base.

B. Analyze the benefits and drawbacks of an ageless character

The agelessness of Sonic comes with both benefits and drawbacks. On one hand, Sonic’s ability to transcend age barriers allows for broader appeal and a larger fan base, ensuring the franchise’s longevity. Sonic’s timeless nature also enables him to adapt to various cultural shifts, remaining relevant and iconic across different generations.

However, the lack of a definitive age for Sonic can sometimes make character development and storytelling challenging. Without a set age, it becomes more difficult to show a linear progression of growth and maturity for Sonic. This can limit the depth of his character and the potential for exploring different stages of his life.

Nevertheless, the agelessness of Sonic has ultimately worked in the franchise’s favor. Sonic’s enduring popularity is a testament to the character’s ability to connect with fans on a deeper level and inspire a sense of wonder and adventure. Whether he remains forever young or has an untold backstory, Sonic’s age ambiguity has cemented his status as a beloved and iconic video game character.

In conclusion, the mystery surrounding Sonic’s age has played a significant role in his enduring popularity. Sonic’s agelessness allows for a broader appeal and captures the imagination of fans of all ages. While it presents some challenges in terms of character development, the benefits of an ageless character far outweigh the drawbacks. Sonic’s age ambiguity adds to his mystique and keeps fans engaged, fostering a dedicated and passionate community. Sonic will continue to run across screens and into the hearts of fans, regardless of the clarity surrounding his age.

The Mystery of Sonic’s Age: Exploring the Enduring Nature of the Ageless Speedster

Introduction

The Sonic the Hedgehog franchise has captivated audiences since its inception, becoming one of the most beloved and iconic video game series of all time. One intriguing facet of Sonic’s character is the mystery of his age, which has sparked countless debates and theories among fans and critics alike.

Sonic’s creation

When Sonic was first created, his age was not a consideration. The focus was primarily on developing a charismatic and relatable character who could rival the popularity of Nintendo’s Mario. His speedy abilities and cool personality were the driving forces behind his creation.

Sonic’s first appearance

Sonic made his debut in the first Sonic the Hedgehog game, released in 1991. Surprisingly, the game and its accompanying materials did not provide any indication of Sonic’s age. This omission only fueled the curiosity surrounding the age of this enigmatic character.

Age hints in Sonic media

Throughout various games in the Sonic franchise, subtle clues about Sonic’s age can be found through his actions and behavior. From his youthful energy to his wit and brashness, these traits suggest a character who is relatively young and full of vitality. Additionally, interactions with other characters provide some context and allow for speculation about Sonic’s age.

Sonic’s friendships

An analysis of Sonic’s relationships with other characters in the franchise offers limited insights into his age. While he often interacts with a diverse range of characters, including Tails, Knuckles, and Amy, their ages do not necessarily provide definitive clues about Sonic’s own age.

Sonic’s physical appearance

As Sonic’s design evolved across different games, there were no significant age-related changes made to his appearance. Instead, the primary focus was on enhancing his iconic, blue hedgehog design and maintaining his youthful and vibrant image.

Sonic’s personality development

Sonic’s personality traits and character growth throughout the series also offer few hints about his age. While there has been some evolution in his character, such as becoming more mature and responsible, it is difficult to determine if these changes directly correspond to an underlying age progression.

Statements from creators

Despite the ongoing speculation, Sonic’s creators have not made any definitive statements regarding his age. Quotes from various creators often avoid the topic altogether, leaving fans to continue their quest for answers.

Fan theories

Fans have presented numerous theories in an attempt to determine Sonic’s age. From analyzing the timeline of events in the games to drawing connections between different Sonic media, each theory offers its own reasoning and evidence. However, without official confirmation or concrete evidence, these theories remain speculative.

Official statements and sources

Though there have been official statements and sources that provide hints about Sonic’s age, they have not offered a concrete answer to this enduring question. Instead, these sources continue to contribute to the ambiguity, maintaining the mystery surrounding Sonic’s age.

Impact of Sonic’s agelessness

The enigmatic nature of Sonic’s age has undoubtedly contributed to his enduring popularity. By remaining ageless, Sonic transcends generational boundaries, appealing to both young and nostalgic players. However, this ambiguity also presents challenges in developing deeper character arcs and exploring mature themes.

Conclusion

As Sonic the Hedgehog continues to thrive and evolve, the mystery surrounding his age remains unsolved. Despite the lack of clarity, Sonic’s enduring character and timeless appeal demonstrate that age is not a defining factor in his continued success. Whether young or old, Sonic will forever hold a place in the hearts of fans around the world.

Leave a Comment