How Many Train Cars Can a Train Pull: Unraveling the Power of Locomotives

Trains have been a vital mode of transportation for centuries, connecting cities, towns, and industries across the globe. At the heart of these impressive machines lies the locomotive, often referred to as the powerhouse of a train. With their immense strength and power, locomotives are capable of pulling remarkably long strings of train cars. However, a fundamental question arises: just how many train cars can a locomotive pull? This article delves into the fascinating world of locomotive power, unraveling the secrets behind their ability to haul heavy loads and examining the factors that determine the maximum number of train cars a locomotive can pull.

The magnitude of a locomotive’s pulling capacity is critical in determining the efficiency and effectiveness of transportation systems. Whether it be freight trains transporting goods across vast distances or passenger trains catering to the needs of commuters, understanding the limitations and capabilities of locomotives provides invaluable insights into the world of rail transport. By shedding light on this topic, we can gain a deeper appreciation for the engineering marvels that facilitate the movement of goods and people, as well as explore the factors that contribute to a locomotive’s strength and ability to pull train cars. So, let us embark on a journey through the intricacies of locomotive power and reveal the secrets behind their impressive hauling capabilities.

Table of Contents

What determines a train’s pulling power?

A. Weight of the train

The weight of the train is one of the primary factors that determine a train’s pulling power. The heavier the train, the more force it will require to move. The weight of the train includes not only the cargo or passenger load but also the weight of the train cars themselves. The more train cars there are in a train, the greater the overall weight and the more power the locomotive will need to generate.

B. Surface conditions

The surface conditions of the tracks also play a crucial role in determining a train’s pulling power. Smooth, well-maintained tracks with good traction allow for efficient movement of the train. On the other hand, tracks that are slippery due to rain, snow, or ice can significantly reduce a train’s pulling power. In such conditions, the locomotive may need to exert more force to overcome the decreased traction, thus affecting the overall pulling capacity.

C. Grade or incline of the track

The grade or incline of the track refers to how steeply it rises or falls. Inclines can pose a significant challenge to the pulling power of a train. When a train moves uphill, it needs to generate additional force to counteract gravity and maintain its speed. Steeper inclines require even more power from the locomotive. On downhill sections, trains can build momentum, but safety measures need to be in place to control the speed, particularly for heavier trains.

D. Power of the locomotive

The power of the locomotive itself is a critical factor in determining a train’s pulling power. Different types of locomotives have varying power capacities. Steam locomotives, diesel-electric locomotives, and electric locomotives each have their own unique power generation systems and capabilities. The design, size, and efficiency of the locomotive’s engine contribute to its overall pulling power. Advancements in locomotive technology have led to more powerful engines, thereby increasing the pulling capacity of trains.

In the next section, we will explore how different types of locomotives generate pulling power and their respective advantages and limitations. By understanding the factors that determine a train’s pulling power, it becomes possible to optimize the efficiency and performance of locomotives, ensuring safe and reliable transportation of goods and passengers.

How locomotives generate pulling power

A. Steam locomotives

Steam locomotives were the earliest form of locomotives used for pulling trains. These locomotives relied on steam power to generate pulling force. Steam was produced by heating water in a boiler, creating high-pressure steam that was then directed to the cylinders. The steam entering the cylinders pushed pistons, which were connected to the wheels through a system of rods and gears. The rotational motion of the wheels allowed the locomotive to move forward and exert pulling power on the train cars.

Steam locomotives had their limitations in terms of pulling power. The size of the boiler limited the amount of steam that could be produced and, therefore, the amount of pulling power that could be generated. As a result, these locomotives were only capable of pulling a limited number of train cars.

B. Diesel-electric locomotives

Diesel-electric locomotives revolutionized the railroad industry with their more efficient and powerful pulling capabilities. These locomotives used a diesel engine to generate electricity, which was then used to power electric motors that drove the wheels. This power conversion allowed for greater control and flexibility in adjusting the pulling power based on the demands of the train.

Diesel-electric locomotives can generate significant pulling power due to their ability to produce large amounts of torque. Torque is the rotational force that can be applied to the wheels, and it directly affects the locomotive’s ability to pull heavy loads. The design and engineering of diesel-electric locomotives have allowed for increased pulling power, enabling them to haul longer and heavier trains compared to steam locomotives.

C. Electric locomotives

Electric locomotives are powered by overhead electrical lines or a third rail that supplies them with electricity. This type of locomotive eliminates the need for onboard fuel storage and combustion, resulting in reduced emissions and increased energy efficiency. Electric locomotives can generate high amounts of pulling power, offering excellent performance for hauling heavy loads.

The electrical energy supplied to electric locomotives is converted into mechanical energy through electric motors connected to the wheels. These motors generate substantial torque, enabling the locomotive to exert a significant pulling force on the train. Electric locomotives have become increasingly popular, especially in areas with access to reliable electric infrastructure, due to their efficiency and environmental benefits.

In conclusion, locomotives generate pulling power through various mechanisms, depending on the type of locomotive. Steam locomotives use steam pressure to drive pistons, while diesel-electric locomotives and electric locomotives employ electric motors powered by diesel engines or electricity, respectively. The advancements in locomotive technology have significantly increased the pulling power capabilities, allowing for the transportation of longer and heavier trains. Furthermore, the use of electric locomotives as a greener alternative has gained prominence, emphasizing the importance of understanding and developing locomotive pulling power.

IHistory of locomotives and their pulling power capabilities

The history of locomotives and their pulling power capabilities is a fascinating journey that showcases the evolution of technology and its impact on the transportation industry. From the early steam locomotives to the modern electric and high-speed trains, each era has witnessed advancements that have significantly increased a train’s pulling power and capacity.

A. Early locomotives and their limitations

In the early days of locomotives, steam engines were the primary source of power. These engines had limited pulling power due to their design and technology constraints. The weight of the train, surface conditions, and track grade also posed challenges for early locomotives, limiting their pulling capacity. Trains were relatively shorter and lighter during this time, and locomotives had to make multiple stops to distribute the load between different engines.

B. Advancements in locomotive technology

As technology progressed, so did the capabilities of locomotives. The invention of the diesel-electric locomotive in the early 20th century revolutionized the industry. These locomotives were more efficient, had greater pulling power, and required less maintenance compared to their steam counterparts. Diesel-electric locomotives became the workhorses of the rail industry, able to pull longer and heavier trains with ease.

C. Impact of technological improvements on pulling capacity

Technological improvements, such as the development of more advanced power systems, propulsion methods, and braking systems, have had a significant impact on a train’s pulling capacity. Electric locomotives, for example, rely on electricity to power their motors, providing a smoother and more consistent pulling force. This technology has allowed for even greater pulling power and the ability to haul heavier loads.

Moreover, the introduction of computer control systems and advanced monitoring technologies has improved the efficiency and overall performance of locomotives. These advancements have enhanced a train’s ability to navigate different track conditions and handle varying weather conditions, further increasing their pulling power.

With each technological leap, locomotives have become more capable of handling larger and heavier trains, making transportation more efficient and economical.

In conclusion, the history of locomotives and their pulling power capabilities showcases the journey of technological advancements that have shaped the rail industry. From the limitations of early steam engines to the powerful and efficient locomotives of today, the evolution of pulling power has been instrumental in the growth and development of railways. With ongoing innovations and future possibilities, locomotives are expected to continue pushing the boundaries of pulling power, making rail transportation even more efficient and sustainable.

Factors to Consider When Determining a Train’s Capacity

A. Maximum Tonnage a Locomotive Can Pull

When determining a train’s capacity, one of the primary factors to consider is the maximum tonnage a locomotive can pull. Each locomotive is designed with a specific pulling capacity, which dictates the amount of weight it can effectively haul. This maximum tonnage is determined by a combination of factors, including the power output of the locomotive, the traction capabilities of its wheels, and the overall structural integrity of the locomotive itself.

B. Train Length Limitations

In addition to the maximum tonnage, train length is another important consideration when determining a train’s capacity. Longer trains require more pulling power to maintain steady acceleration and to overcome the inertia caused by the additional mass. Trains that are too long for the locomotive’s pulling capacity can experience reduced performance, increased wear and tear on the locomotive, and potentially dangerous situations, such as inadequate braking capabilities.

C. Coupling Strength of Train Cars

The coupling strength of train cars is also a crucial factor in determining a train’s capacity. The couplers, the mechanical connectors that join the train cars, must be able to withstand the forces exerted during acceleration, deceleration, and while navigating varying track conditions. Weak or insufficient couplers can lead to coupler failures, which can result in derailments or train separations.

D. Impact of Weather Conditions

Weather conditions play a significant role in a train’s capacity. Adverse weather conditions, such as heavy rain, snow, or high winds, can reduce traction between the wheels and the tracks, potentially limiting a train’s pulling power. Additionally, extreme temperatures can affect the performance of the locomotive’s engine, potentially reducing its power output and overall capacity.

It is essential for engineers and operators to carefully consider these factors when determining a train’s capacity. Failure to account for these variables can result in operational inefficiencies, safety concerns, and potential damage to the locomotive and train cars.

Overall, understanding the various factors that contribute to a train’s capacity is crucial for ensuring safe and efficient rail operations. Advances in locomotive technology continue to push the boundaries of pulling power, allowing for more efficient and capable train operations. By carefully considering maximum tonnage, train length limitations, coupling strength, and weather conditions, railway operators can optimize train performance and enhance the overall efficiency of their operations.

Pulling power tests and standards

A. The Association of American Railroads (AAR) standards

The Association of American Railroads (AAR) has established standardized tests and guidelines to determine the pulling power of locomotives. These standards ensure consistency and safety in the industry.

The AAR standards include various tests to assess the maximum pulling capacity of a locomotive. These tests take into account factors such as weight, surface conditions, grade of the track, and the power output of the locomotive.

B. Break-in tests

Break-in tests are conducted on new locomotives to assess their pulling power. During these tests, the locomotive is gradually subjected to increasing loads while operating at different speeds. This process allows the locomotive’s components to set and align properly, ensuring optimal performance.

The break-in tests also help identify any initial issues or abnormalities in the locomotive’s power delivery. Once the locomotive passes the break-in period, its pulling power can be accurately determined.

C. Continuous tractive effort tests

Continuous tractive effort tests measure the pulling power of locomotives under continuously varying loads and speeds. This test simulates real-world operating conditions and provides a comprehensive assessment of a locomotive’s pulling capacity.

During the continuous tractive effort test, the locomotive is subjected to different levels of resistance while pulling a train. The test measures the force required to overcome the resistance and maintain a consistent speed. This data is then analyzed to determine the maximum tractive effort the locomotive can exert.

These tests enable rail operators and manufacturers to understand the limits and capabilities of locomotives, ensuring safe and efficient train operations.

By adhering to AAR standards and conducting pulling power tests, the railway industry can accurately assess the pulling capacity of locomotives. This information is essential for determining train capacities, planning freight shipments, and ensuring the overall safety and efficiency of rail transportation. Continued advancements in locomotive technology and testing methodologies will further enhance the understanding and utilization of a train’s pulling power.

Examples of different types of trains and their pulling power

A. Freight trains

Freight trains are an essential part of the transportation industry, responsible for hauling goods across long distances. These trains are known for their impressive pulling power, as they often carry heavy loads. The pulling power of a freight train depends on various factors such as the weight of the train, the power of the locomotive, and the conditions of the track.

Modern freight trains can pull an average of 5,000 to 8,000 tons of cargo. However, exceptiona trains, such as the Union Pacific Big Boy, have been known to haul over 13,000 tons of freight. These trains typically consist of multiple locomotives working together to distribute the load evenly and maximize pulling power. The power of diesel-electric locomotives used in freight trains allows them to generate sufficient tractive effort to overcome the weight and friction of the cargo.

B. Passenger trains

Passenger trains are designed to transport people rather than goods. While they may not carry as much weight as freight trains, their pulling power is still significant. The ability to pull heavy loads in the case of commuter trains is crucial to meet the demands of densely populated areas.

The pulling power of passenger trains is determined by factors such as the weight of the train cars and the power of the locomotive. Electric locomotives are commonly used in passenger trains due to their ability to provide high levels of power and efficiency. High-speed passenger trains, such as the Shinkansen in Japan, rely on powerful electric locomotives to achieve speeds of over 200 miles per hour.

C. High-speed trains

High-speed trains are capable of reaching remarkable speeds and require significant pulling power to maintain their velocity. These trains utilize advanced technologies and streamlined designs to reduce air resistance, allowing them to operate efficiently at high speeds.

High-speed trains often use electric locomotives powered by overhead catenary systems or on-board batteries. These locomotives generate substantial tractive effort to overcome the resistance caused by high speeds. The Thalys, Eurostar, and TGV are examples of high-speed trains that have achieved remarkable pulling power while maintaining passenger comfort and safety.

In conclusion, the pulling power of different types of trains varies depending on their design, purpose, and technological advancements. Freight trains, passenger trains, and high-speed trains all require substantial pulling power to transport goods or people efficiently. The continued innovation in locomotive technology, such as hybrid locomotives and advancements in artificial intelligence, holds the promise of further increasing the pulling power of trains, making them more efficient and sustainable for future transportation needs.

World records for train pulling power

A. Historical records

When it comes to train pulling power, there have been numerous remarkable achievements throughout history. One of the most well-known records dates back to 1867 when the Central Pacific Railroad set a record by having a single locomotive pull a train weighing an impressive 131 cars. This record-breaking feat showcased the immense capabilities of locomotives of that time.

Moving forward to the 20th century, the Norfolk and Western Railway set another remarkable record in 1952. Their Y6-class locomotive pulled a train weighing a staggering 176 cars, highlighting the advancement in locomotive power and engineering.

B. Modern records

In recent years, there have been notable advancements in locomotive technology, leading to even more extraordinary train pulling power records. In 1999, the Union Pacific Railroad set a new record for pulling the heaviest train. Their modern freight locomotive, known as the AC6000CW, pulled a 17,000-ton train. This incredible achievement demonstrated the immense progress made in locomotive power and efficiency.

Another modern record was set by a Chinese railway company in 2015. Using a specially designed locomotive, they pulled a train consisting of 216 loaded cars, weighing an astounding 17,000 tons. This breakthrough showcased the growing capabilities of locomotives in terms of pulling power and efficiency.

C. Notable achievements in train pulling power

Apart from the historical and modern records, there have been numerous other notable achievements in train pulling power. One such achievement is the Big Boy, a steam locomotive built by the American Locomotive Company. With a wheel arrangement of 4-8-8-4, the Big Boy was the largest and most powerful steam locomotive ever built. It could pull incredibly long and heavy trains, making it a symbol of locomotive strength.

In recent years, there have been advancements in electric locomotives as well. The Siemens Vectron locomotive, for instance, can pull heavy freight trains efficiently while using electric motors. This represents a significant step towards greener and more sustainable train operations.

Overall, the world records and notable achievements in train pulling power demonstrate the continuous progress in locomotive technology. These accomplishments serve as a testament to the ingenuity and advancements made in designing locomotives with immense pulling capacity, ultimately contributing to the efficiency and effectiveness of rail transportation systems.

Challenges Faced by Locomotives and Limitations on Pulling Power

Steep Inclines

One of the major challenges faced by locomotives in terms of pulling power is steep inclines or gradients on the tracks. As a train moves uphill, the force required to overcome gravity increases significantly. This means that the pulling power of the locomotive needs to be strong enough to counteract the weight of the train and the force of gravity pulling it down. If the locomotive does not have sufficient power, it may struggle to pull the train up the incline and may even come to a halt.

Heavy Loads

The weight or tonnage of the train is another crucial factor that can limit a locomotive’s pulling power. As the weight of the train increases, the force required to move it also increases. Therefore, locomotives need to be powerful enough to generate sufficient pulling force to overcome the weight of the train. If the load exceeds the locomotive’s maximum pulling capacity, it may not be able to move the train or may strain its engine and other mechanical components.

Seasonal Effects

Seasonal effects, such as extreme weather conditions, can also pose challenges to locomotives and impact their pulling power. For example, during winter, snow and ice can accumulate on the tracks, making them slippery and reducing traction. This can make it more difficult for the locomotive to generate enough pulling force to move the train. Additionally, extreme heat can affect the performance of the locomotive’s engine, causing it to lose power and potentially impacting its pulling capacity.

In conclusion, locomotives face several challenges and limitations when it comes to their pulling power. Steep inclines, heavy loads, and seasonal effects can all impact a locomotive’s ability to generate sufficient pulling force. It is essential for operators and engineers to carefully consider these factors when determining a train’s capacity and planning routes. Advances in locomotive technology, such as hybrid locomotives and artificial intelligence, offer potential solutions to overcome these challenges and improve pulling power. Understanding the challenges and limitations faced by locomotives can lead to innovations and future developments that push the boundaries of their pulling power capabilities.

Innovations and Future Developments in Locomotive Pulling Power

A. Hybrid Locomotives

As the push for more environmentally friendly transportation options grows, the development of hybrid locomotives has become an area of focus for engineers and researchers. Hybrid locomotives combine traditional diesel engines with electric power sources to reduce emissions and increase fuel efficiency.

The diesel engine in a hybrid locomotive is used to generate electricity, which is then stored in batteries. This stored energy can be utilized during acceleration or in areas where noise or emissions restrictions may be in place, such as tunnels or urban areas. By leveraging the benefits of both diesel and electric power, hybrid locomotives have the potential to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions while maintaining the necessary pulling power to move heavy loads.

B. Maglev Technology

Magnetic levitation, or maglev, technology is another area of innovation that could have a significant impact on locomotive pulling power. Maglev trains use powerful magnets to levitate above the track, eliminating the need for traditional wheels and allowing for higher speeds and smoother rides.

While maglev trains are currently primarily used for passenger transportation, the technology holds potential for freight transportation as well. With reduced friction, maglev trains could potentially pull longer and heavier loads with greater efficiency. However, the development and implementation of maglev technology for freight trains present unique challenges, such as adapting the technology to accommodate the variable loads and sizes of freight cars.

C. Artificial Intelligence Advancements

Artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize many industries, including locomotive pulling power. By leveraging AI algorithms, locomotives can optimize their performance based on factors such as weight, track conditions, and weather. AI can analyze real-time data and adjust the traction and power distribution to maximize efficiency and minimize energy consumption.

The use of AI can also enhance safety by predicting and preventing potential issues, such as derailments or equipment failures. By continuously learning from operational data, AI-powered locomotives can improve their performance over time, leading to more reliable and efficient pulling power.

In conclusion, the future of locomotive pulling power lies in innovative technologies such as hybrid locomotives, maglev technology, and artificial intelligence advancements. These developments not only offer the potential for increased efficiency and reduced environmental impact but also drive the industry towards a more sustainable and intelligent future. As researchers and engineers continue to explore and implement these advancements, the power of locomotives and their pulling capacity will continue to evolve, shaping the future of rail transportation.

Environmental considerations of train pulling power

A. Carbon emissions and fuel efficiency

One of the key environmental considerations when it comes to train pulling power is the impact on carbon emissions and fuel efficiency. Traditional locomotives, such as diesel-electric ones, are known to produce significant amounts of carbon emissions during operation. This is because they rely on the combustion of fossil fuels, primarily diesel, to generate power. As a result, these locomotives contribute to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, which have detrimental effects on the environment and human health.

Fuel efficiency is also an important factor to consider. Trains that have higher fuel efficiency can cover longer distances with less fuel consumption, thereby reducing overall carbon emissions. Advances in locomotive technology, such as improved engine designs and hybrid locomotives, have aimed to increase fuel efficiency and reduce the environmental impact of train pulling power.

B. Electric locomotives as a greener alternative

Electric locomotives have emerged as a greener alternative to traditional locomotives. Unlike diesel-electric locomotives, electric locomotives are powered by electricity, which can be generated from renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power. This significantly reduces or eliminates carbon emissions during operation, making electric locomotives more environmentally friendly.

In terms of fuel efficiency, electric locomotives have the potential to be highly efficient. Electric motors are known for their high efficiency, and when paired with regenerative braking systems, they can recover and reuse energy that would otherwise be lost during braking. This further improves the overall fuel efficiency of electric locomotives.

The adoption of electric locomotives can not only reduce carbon emissions and improve fuel efficiency but also contribute to lower operational costs in the long run. While the initial investment in electrification infrastructure may be significant, the savings in fuel costs over time can outweigh the upfront expenses.

In conclusion, considering the environmental impact of train pulling power is crucial. Carbon emissions and fuel efficiency play significant roles in determining the sustainability of locomotives. Electric locomotives offer a greener alternative with reduced carbon emissions and improved fuel efficiency. Embracing electric locomotives, along with continuous advancements in locomotive technology, can pave the way for a more sustainable and environmentally friendly future for train transportation.

Unconventional uses of train pulling power

A. Pulling non-train loads

Train pulling power is not limited to dragging train cars along tracks. In fact, locomotives have been utilized for several unconventional purposes throughout history. One notable example is the transportation of massive objects that cannot be moved using traditional methods.

The immense power generated by locomotives allows them to pull loads that would be impossible for other vehicles. In various industries, trains have been used to pull heavy machinery, construction equipment, and even entire buildings. This unconventional use of train pulling power has proven to be efficient and cost-effective, especially for transporting oversized cargo.

One famous instance of using locomotives to pull non-train loads occurred in 1917 when a steam locomotive was employed to haul a 650-ton artillery gun during World War I. The locomotive successfully pulled the heavy load, showcasing the incredible strength of these machines.

B. Industrial applications

In addition to pulling non-train loads, train pulling power has found practical applications in different industries. For instance, in mining operations, locomotives are utilized to transport ore and other materials from deep within mines to the surface. The powerful pulling capabilities of locomotives enable efficient extraction and transportation of large quantities of resources.

Furthermore, the agriculture sector has also benefited from train pulling power. Locomotives are used to pull specialized grain hopper cars, allowing for the efficient transportation of crops from farms to processing facilities or markets. With their ability to handle substantial loads, locomotives have greatly facilitated the movement of agricultural products, reducing transportation costs and increasing productivity.

Moreover, the industrial sector heavily relies on locomotive pulling power for transporting heavy industrial equipment and raw materials. Locomotives are employed for hauling steel coils, machinery, and other industrial goods between manufacturing facilities, warehouses, and distribution centers. The efficiency and reliability of using locomotives for these purposes have made them an integral part of industrial supply chains.

Overall, train pulling power extends beyond traditional train operations and has demonstrated its versatility in various industries. The immense strength and capabilities of locomotives have allowed for the transportation of non-train loads and facilitated industrial applications. As technology continues to advance, it is likely that new and even more unconventional uses for train pulling power will emerge, further expanding the potential of locomotives in different sectors.

Conclusion

A. Importance of understanding a train’s pulling power

Understanding a train’s pulling power is crucial for the safe and efficient operation of locomotives. By comprehending the factors that determine pulling capacity and the limitations faced by locomotives, railway operators can make informed decisions regarding train composition, scheduling, and maintenance. Failure to consider these factors can lead to accidents, delays, and increased fuel consumption.

B. Advances in locomotive technology and future possibilities

Over the years, locomotive technology has evolved significantly, resulting in substantial improvements in pulling power. From the early steam locomotives to the modern electric and diesel-electric locomotives, innovations have revolutionized the industry. The development of hybrid locomotives, which combine multiple power sources, shows promise in further boosting pulling power while reducing carbon emissions.

Maglev technology, which uses magnetic levitation to eliminate the need for traditional wheels and tracks, has the potential to set new records for pulling power. The absence of friction allows maglev trains to reach higher speeds and pull heavier loads, making them a game-changer in the transportation industry. Additionally, advancements in artificial intelligence can optimize locomotive performance and enhance pulling power by autonomously managing power distribution and fine-tuning operations.

C. Environmental considerations of train pulling power

As concerns about climate change grow, the environmental impact of train pulling power becomes a crucial consideration. Traditional locomotives powered by diesel engines produce significant amounts of carbon emissions, contributing to air pollution and climate change. Electric locomotives, on the other hand, offer a greener alternative by relying on electricity and producing zero direct emissions.

To reduce carbon emissions and improve fuel efficiency, railway operators are increasingly adopting electric locomotives. The electrification of rail networks and the use of renewable energy sources for electricity generation are helping mitigate the environmental impact of train operations. Additionally, initiatives such as regenerative braking, which converts braking energy into electricity, further enhance the efficiency of electric locomotives.

In conclusion, understanding a train’s pulling power is integral to the successful operation of locomotives. Advances in locomotive technology, such as hybrid locomotives and maglev technology, hold promise for further improving pulling power capabilities. Additionally, the shift towards electric locomotives and the adoption of greener practices contribute to reducing the environmental impact of train operations. As the railway industry continues to evolve, it is essential to monitor and embrace future developments to ensure safer, more efficient, and environmentally sustainable rail transportation.

Leave a Comment